What are artificial sweeteners? Are they any superior to sugar in terms of their impact on the physique and weight?

Those who have a sweet tooth may gravitate to artificial sweeteners, which provide a sugary taste without sugar or calories. 

Artificial sweeteners are a hot topic of discussion. On the one hand, they’re said to raise cancer risk and impair blood sugar and digestive health.

On the other hand, most public health officials regard them as acceptable, and many individuals use them to cut down on sweets and lose weight.

Artificial sweeteners have been linked with weight gain, brain tumors, bladder cancer, and other health issues in animals.

Humans have experienced several health-related negative effects, including carcinogenicity. These drugs have been the subject of numerous investigations, ranging from “safe under all conditions” to “unsafe at any dose.”

What are artificial sweeteners?

What are artificial sweeteners? “Artificial sweeteners, often known as high-intensity or sugar replacements, are often sweeter than sugar but contain few calories,” says Lynn Grieger, RDN, CDE.

Artificial sweeteners, sometimes known as sugar substitutes, are substances used to sweeten meals and beverages.

They’re commonly referred to as “strong sweeteners” since they taste similar to table sugar but are thousands of times sweeter.

According to the Journal of In Food Science and Food Safety, although certain sweeteners contain calories, the amount required to sweeten items is so minimal that you consume virtually no calories.

How do artificial sweeteners work?

Many taste buds are present on the top of your tongue, each with numerous taste receptors identifying distinct flavors.

When you consume, food molecules come into contact with your taste receptors. When a receptor and molecule are perfectly aligned, a signal is sent to your brain, allowing you to recognize the flavor.

The sugar molecule, for instance, integrates seamlessly into your sweet taste receptor, enabling your central nervous system(brain) to identify the sweet taste (source).

The molecules of artificial sweeteners are identical enough to sugar molecules to interact with the sweetness receptor.

According to In Food Science and Food Safety, they are, however, too dissimilar from sugar for your system to convert them to calories. That’s how they achieve a sweet flavor without adding extra calories.

Types of artificial sweetener:

As the name implies, artificial sweeteners are substances that give sweetness to food or drink by using a variety of chemicals rather than sugar.

They typically include no calories and, of course, no sugar. The artificial sweetener market is vast, and there are several different varieties to select from since many Americans want to avoid sugar without radically changing their diets.

According to the FDA and Food Standards Agency, the following artificial sweeteners are permitted in the United States and the European Union.

  • A sweetener, commercialized under the brand name Newtame, is 13,000 times stronger than table sugar and can be used in cooking and baking.
  • It’s 340 times stronger than table sugar and can be used in baking, cooking, and mixing acidic meals. It is important to note that it has not been licensed for users in the U.s.
  • Saccharin is 700 times stronger than table sugar and is marketed names Sweet’N Low, Sweet Twin, or Necta Sweet.
  • Sucralose, a 600-fold stronger version of table sugar, is ideal for cooking, baking, and blending with acidic dishes. Splenda is the registered trademark for this product.
  • Aspartame is 200 times stronger than table sugar and is marketed under NutraSweet, Equal, or Sugar Twin.
  • Potassium acesulfame. It’s 200 times stronger than table sugar and is also recognized as acesulfame K. It’s supplied under the Sunset or Sweet One brands and is suitable for cooking and baking.
  • This sugar substitute is 20,000 times richer than table sugar and can be used in cooking and baking.
  • Aspartame-acesulfame salt. It’s 350 times richer than table sugar and is branded by Twinsweet.
  • Cooking and baking are done with cyclamate, which is 50times stronger than table sugar. In the United States, though, it has been prohibited since 1970.

Side effects of artificial sweeteners

The following are some of the side effects of artificial sweeteners:

Negative impact on the brain

Some evidence suggests that artificial sweeteners pass the blood-brain barrier and alter hippocampus function when consumed.

According to endocrinologist Rocio Salas-Whalen, MD, artificial sweeteners diminish responsiveness to interceptive signals. They can also cause irregular appetite, which encourages food intake.

Unhealthy for the digestive system

The 2014 nature study found that regular use of sugar substitutes including saccharin, sucralose, and aspartame resulted in a strange mix of bacteria in the gut, which increased the risk of insulin reduced sensitivity (a precursor to diabetes) weight gain,” Ogunyemi notes.

“One way this could happen is that because the artificial sweetener lingers in your stomach and isn’t absorbed, it’s utilized as ‘food’ for dangerous bacteria, leading them to thrive while the healthier bugs die off.”

Gut bacteria makeup and function differ by individual and are influenced by what you consume, even artificial sweeteners.

According to one study, the artificial sweetener saccharin altered gut microbial balance in four out of seven normal individuals.

After five days after ingesting the artificial sweetener, the four “responders” demonstrated poorer blood sugar management.

Furthermore, when these people’s gut microorganisms were implanted into mice, the mice had poor blood sugar control.

The mice injected with “non-responder” gut flora, on the other hand, showed no alterations in their capacity to control blood sugar levels. Although intriguing, further research is required before firm conclusions are drawn.

Gut bacteria play a critical role in your health, and poor gut health has been related to various issues. Some of these include gaining weight, lack of blood sugar control, metabolic disorders, a weaker immune system, and sleep disturbances.

Diabetes and artificial sweeteners       

Artificial sweeteners have been shown in several controlled experiments not to affect blood sugar or insulin levels (sources 1,2,3,4,5).

Only one tiny study among Hispanic women has indicated a negative effect thus far. Compared to women who drank water before drinking a sugary drink, those who consumed an artificially sweetened drink before having a sugary drink had 14 percent higher blood sugar levels and 20 percent higher insulin levels.

However, the research participants were not accustomed to drinking artificially sweetened beverages, which could explain some of the findings.

Furthermore, artificial sweeteners may influence different persons depending on their age or genetic heritage.

For example, research reveals that switching from sugar-sweetened to artificially sweetened beverages had a higher impact on Hispanic youth.

Artificial sweeteners can reprogram taste buds

And it’s not always for the best. Tanya Freirich, MS, RD, CDN, CDE, nutritionist for Sweet Nova, stated, “You and your taste receptors become addicted to highly sweet stuff because artificial sweeteners have several times the intensity of sweet flavor compared to natural sugars.”

“Those who ingest artificial sweeteners may develop a taste for extreme sweetness. It could alter their taste preferences and reduce their enjoyment of naturally sweet meals such as fresh fruit and healthful foods that are slightly bitter, such as whole grains or vegetables.”

Weight gain

Artificial sweeteners slow down your digestion by disrupting the body’s insulin and glucose equilibrium. Your brain interprets this as being hungrier, contributing to excess eating.

According to the Journal of Nature, artificial sweeteners were once thought to be a safe weight-loss choice because of their low-calorie appeal. Now, artificial sweeteners are now known to change the gut microbiota, resulting in weight gain.

Effects on hunger

Some think artificial sweeteners enhance hunger and cause weight gain. According to this study, artificial sweeteners may be unable to activate the food reward pathway, which is required to make you feel satiated after eating.

It’s even been argued that sweets may trigger sugary food cravings. However, numerous recent research has found that artificial sweeteners do not enhance hunger or calorie consumption.

According to studies, when sugary meals are replaced with artificially sweetened alternatives, participants report feeling less hungry and consuming fewer calories.

They’re supposed to trick the brain into thinking it’s still hungry because they taste sweet yet don’t have the calories of other sweet-tasting foods.

Furthermore, some scientists believe that you need to consume more of an artificially sweetened item to feel full than a sugar-sweetened counterpart.

There are calories in some artificial sweeteners

Artificial sweeteners are classified as either non-nutritive or edible, with the majority falling under the non-nutritive category.

Synthetic sugar substitutes that are calorie and carbohydrate-free are known as non-nutritive sweeteners. The Journal of Food Science and Technology says that they can be made from plants or herbs that grow naturally and are much sweeter than sugar.

The nutritive group, which solely includes aspartame, is the other type of artificial sweetener. Nutritive sweeteners may have fewer calories than sugar, but they add caloric value to products containing them.

Cancer and artificial sweeteners

The argument over whether artificial sweeteners are linked to cancer risk has raged since the 1970s.

Animal Research discovered a higher risk of bladder cancer in mice fed exceptionally high levels of saccharin and cyclamate, which sparked the debate. Saccharin is metabolized differently in mice than in humans.

Since then, more than 30 humans investigations have revealed no evidence of a relationship between artificial sweeteners and cancer risk.

Artificial sweetener consumption has been linked to an increase in the size of malignant tumors.

Aspartame, one of the most harmful artificial sweeteners, has been labeled a “multi-potent carcinogenic substance” by researchers. Another study called aspartame intake in the United States an “urgent problem.”

According to The Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine, aspartame is found in 974 foods, including diet soda, sugar-free ice cream, sugar-free sweets, morning cereals, gum, yogurt, and coffee creamer, to name a few.

Headaches, depression, and seizures caused by aspartame

Artificial sweeteners can induce unpleasant side effects like headaches, depression, and seizures in some people.

Scientists have discovered a link between artificial sweetener-rich diets and sadness and irritability.

While most research shows no link between aspartame and headaches, two mentions that some people are more susceptible than others, and individual differences in aspartame’s effects on depression may also apply.

According to the Journal of Biological Psychiatry, people with mental problems, for example, may be more likely to experience depressive symptoms due to aspartame use.

If you suffer from sadness or irritability, consider eliminating sugar and artificial sweeteners for one to two weeks.

In addition, make sure you’re receiving enough sleep and drink—many people see an instant change in their mood.

artificial sweetener packets in dishes

Metabolic syndromes and artificial sweeteners

The term “metabolic syndrome” refers to medical problems that include high blood pressure, diabetes, abdominal fat, and abnormal cholesterol levels.

According to some research, diet soda consumers are up to 36% more likely to develop metabolic syndrome.

On the other hand, Higher-Quality Research shows that diet soda has either no effect or a protective effect.

People with obesity and excess weight were given a quarter gallon (1 liter) of regular soda, diet soda, freshwater, or semi-skimmed milk to drink each day in a recent study.

When contrast to those who drank regular soda, those who drank diet soda lost 17–21% of their weight, had 24–31% less stomach fat, 32% lower cholesterol, and 10%–15% lower blood pressure by the finish of the six-month research.

Cardiovascular disease

Artificial sugar consumption has been linked to obesity, which can unnecessarily strain your heart muscles. Cardiac arrest, stroke, and hypertension are examples of cardiometabolic disorders.

Furthermore, you’re at a higher risk if you smoke or even have a family history of cardiovascular illness.

Artificial sweeteners during pregnancy

For years, scientists have debated the safety of aspartame and sucralose, two artificial sweeteners often found in diet drinks and sugarless candy or gum, when consumed while pregnant.

According to studies, children whose moms used artificial sweeteners while pregnant and lactating had a higher prevalence of obesity and cardio-metabolic problems.

There is additional evidence that artificial sweetener usage before birth causes weight growth in newborns and is linked to preterm birth.

Memory loss, dementia, and stroke

Artificially sweetened soft drinks were implicated in the development of stroke, dementia, and Alzheimer’s disease, according to a 2017 study, whereas sugar-sweetened soft drinks were not.

Of course, this does not zero the possibility of harm from sugar consumption, but it emphasizes the need to consume only naturally occurring compounds in your diet.

IBS and Crohn’s disease

According to the Journal of Inflammatory Bowel Diseases, the microbiota in your gut—the powerhouse of your digestion and immune system—is altered by high consumption of artificial sweeteners like Splenda (another name for sucralose).

Artificial sweeteners have also been related to gut irritability and, in some situations, can precipitate Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) and Crohn’s disease in those who are predisposed.

Liver damage 

According to studies, increased usage of artificial sweeteners (particularly in soft drinks) causes lipid (fat) excess deposition in the liver, fibrosis, and liver deterioration.

Should replace soft drinks with sparkling water, tea, or kombucha. The liver is your body’s detoxification powerhouse, and you don’t want to put any more strain on its ability to detoxify!

So, what are artificial sweeteners?

Artificial sweeteners come in various flavors, and there is a lot of conflicting evidence on how they affect your health. Here’s all you need to learn about the subject:

  • Artificial sweeteners have their own set of concerns, even though they lack many of the harmful health impacts of sugar.
  • These sweeteners can have a variety of negative effects, including headaches, depression, increased cancer risk, weight gain owing to increased appetite, and the two difficulties (impact on gut health and increased diabetes risk).
  • Artificial sweeteners have been demonstrated in studies to change the makeup of bacteria in the gut microbiome, thus impacting gut health.
  • Many doctors are unaware of the health hazards associated with artificial sweeteners and hence fail to inform their patients. Furthermore, studies funded by special interests may appear to “prove” the safety of artificial sweeteners.
  • Choose a healthful sweetener like honey or genuine maple syrup rather than sugar or artificial sweeteners.
  • Poor blood sugar regulation is one of the side effects of this changed microbiome, which increases the risk of type 2 diabetes.
  • Artificial sweeteners are a sweetener that doesn’t include any calories or sugar. Most are created in a lab, but plants take up some (such as stevia).
  • Saccharine (Sweet’N Low), aspartame (Equal), sucralose (Splenda), and stevia are the most used artificial sweeteners in the United States.

Phenylketonuria (PKU) is a rare metabolic condition in which people are unable to metabolize the amino acid phenylalanine, which is contained in aspartame. Aspartame should be avoided by persons with PKU.

Furthermore, some people are allergic to sulfonamides, which is the chemical class that saccharin belongs to. Saccharin can cause respiratory problems, rashes, and diarrhea in them.

Furthermore, there is mounting evidence that certain artificial sweeteners, such as sucralose, impair insulin sensitivity and alter gut microbes.

Other Related Articles

  1. Health Benefits Of Oatmeal
  2. How Much Water Should You Drink A Day To Lose Weight?
  3. What Are Blue Zones?
  4. Incredible Health Benefits Of NAC
  5. Surprising Health Benefits Of Walking Everyday

If you enjoyed this post, “What Are Artificial Sweeteners”, and would love to see more, join me on YoutubeInstagramFacebook & Twitter!

Get discounted copies of my cookbook here.

Fortunately, because of the ads on our website, readers and subscribers of Healthier Steps are sponsoring many underprivileged families.