Vegan Cheddar Cheese

This flavorful Vegan Cheddar Cheese recipe is so yummy, that even the pickiest eater will love it! It is smooth, creamy, sharp, and reminiscent of the cheese I grew up eating.

This Vegan Cheddar Cheese recipe is so easy to prepare and it actually tastes better than most commercial recipes. It is sliceable, so it is perfect to serve with sandwiches or as an appetizer.

I have been wanting to make sliceable vegan cheese for quite a while after purchasing agar powder from my local Asian market. Agar powder can also be found online here.

My cheese sauce recipe from my Vegan Mac and Cheese recipe is so delicious, that I decided to make the sliceable Vegan Cheddar Cheese by modifying the recipe. The result was spot on, it was so delicious that even my daughter, who is very picky, loved it.

I served my vegan cheese with my Brown Rice Crackers and it was such a delightful treat.

FOR THE FULL LIST OF INGREDIENTS, SCROLL TO SEE THE RECIPE CARD AT THE END. BUT BEFORE YOU SCROLL CHECK THE IMPORTANT INFORMATION THAT IS INCLUDED IN THE BLURB.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe?

This amazing Vegan Cheddar Cheese Recipe is great for your next event and will certainly be a huge hit because:

• It’s rich, cheesy, hearty, and comforting.
• It’s nutritious, gentle on the stomach, and delicious.
• It tastes amazing!
• It is vegan, gluten-free, and dairy-free.
• A batch may be prepared in under 10 minutes.
• You can slice and grate it.
• You may even make a variant that melts and stretches!
• It tastes like real cheddar cheese.
• This recipe is a lot cheaper than buying vegan cheese or making cashew cheese at home.
• Spices are mild, however, they can be increased or decreased according to your taste buds.

What is Vegan Cheese?

Vegan cheese is plant-based cheese made for people who are avoiding animal products in their diet.

It is also great for people who are dairy-free or lactose intolerant, those who are transitioning to a vegan lifestyle, and those who are exploring non-traditional foods.

Cheese is basically made from the coagulation of proteins. In traditional cheese, this protein is casein which is derived from animal milk.

Rennet, a group of enzymes that are produced from the stomach of cows, is added to coagulate the casein. This is what causes curdling and cheese production.

However, vegan cheese doesn’t contain any animal protein. Instead, thickeners, oils, and plant proteins are used to produce firm vegan cheese.

What is Agar-Agar?

Agar-Agar, also known as, Japanese gelatin, vegetable gelatin, Chinese isinglass, or China glass, is the ingredient of choice for making solid vegan cheese, it is a jelly-like product from seaweed. It is basically the vegan version of gelatin.

Agar-agar is sold in Asian supermarkets and most health food stores, it is sold in powdered form, flakes, or bar. It is also great in puddings, soups, and mousse. For every 1 teaspoon of powdered form, you will need 1 tablespoon of flakes or 1/2 bar.

Ingredients Descriptions:

• Cashews: Cashews for creamy, velvety cheese and a good source of protein
• Red Bell Pepper: Red bell pepper for orange color and vitamins.
• Nutritional Yeast Flakes: Nutritional yeast flakes for cheesy flavor and Vitamin B12.
• Lemon Juice: Adds a great zing and brightness to the dish.
• Coconut Milk: Plant-based milk is known as non-dairy milk. Almond milk, coconut milk, soy milk, and cashew milk are some of the varieties. I chose coconut milk, but feel free to use your fave! Any type of plant-based milk will work.
• Non-Gmo Cornstarch: Depending on the desired consistency of the sauce, you can increase or decrease the amount of cornstarch.
• Granulated Onion Powder: The addition of onion powder will give this cheese a more savory flavor.
• Granulated Garlic Powder: Garlic powder gives it a rich garlicky flavor.
• Salt: Salt brings the flavors together and makes the recipe complete.
• Cayenne Pepper: It imparts a more neutral “peppery” flavor to the cheddar cheese.
• Water
• Agar Powder: This clear vegan gelatin, which is made from seaweed, is crucial for setting the cheese. If you omit it, you cannot get sliceable cheese. If you can get it, use agar agar powder instead of flakes. It can be pricey, but if you get it from Amazon, it’s a terrific deal.

How To Make Vegan Cheddar Cheese?

To make this vegan cheese recipe:

1. Blend cashews, water, nutritional yeast flakes, bell pepper, cornstarch, coconut milk, coconut oil, lemon juice, onion powder, garlic powder, and salt until very creamy.
2. Boil the agar powder in water and immediately add it to the cashew sauce.
3. Blend the agar/cashew mixture again in a high-speed blender until smooth.
4. Pour the cheese mixture into a mold and refrigerate for a couple of hours.

What is Agar-Agar?

Agar-Agar,  also known as, Japanese gelatin, vegetable gelatin, Chinese isinglass, China glass, is the ingredient of choice for making solid vegan cheese, it is a jelly-like product from seaweed. It is basically the vegan version of gelatin.

Agar-agar is sold in Asian supermarkets and most health food stores, it is sold in powdered form, flakes or bar. It is also great in puddings, soups, mousse. For every 1 teaspoon of powdered form, you will need 1 tablespoon of flakes or 1/2 bar.

• How Long Does Homemade Vegan Cheese Last In The Fridge?

  Your vegan cheese should last around 5-7 days in the refrigerator stored in a covered container.

  Storage Suggestions

  Refrigerator: Refrigerate the cheese in an airtight container for up to 5 days.

  It can be frozen for up to three months. I find it simplest to freeze the cheese in an airtight freezer bag after slicing or shredding it. This allows you to utilize smaller pieces without having to defrost the entire block.

  Serving Suggestions

  This vegan cheddar is delicious shredded on pizza, salads, sandwiches, or either diced or sliced for snacking! It is just as delicious as regular cheddar cheese.

  Top Tips

  Check out these helpful tips for the finest vegan cheddar  cheese:

  • Add tahini paste for an added cheesy flavor. If you don’t have tahini you can replace it with miso.
  • Ensure that you accurately measure the ingredients! Your cheese’s texture can be significantly altered by little adjustments to the liquid, agar agar, or tapioca starch amounts.
  • Allow the agar agar to melt and completely bind with the ingredients by simmering.
  • If you want the cheese to melt while making anything hot, such as a grilled cheese sandwich, use tapioca starch.
  • In order to achieve the velvety cheese sauce, I highly recommend you use a high-speed blender like Blendtec or
  • If you do not have a high-speed blender, soak your cashews first. I also recommend that you blend at least two times resting the blender after each time you process the sauce to prevent your motor from getting damaged.
  • You may add more or less water depending on the consistency you choose.
  • It’s much better to make it a little bit thick, which can be readily adjusted, than being too thin, which can’t.
  • Store in an airtight container for up to 5 days in the refrigerator or three months in the freezer.

  Other Amazing Vegan Cheese Recipes To Try

  • Vegan Cheese Ball
  • Vegan Pepper Jack Cheese
  • Nacho Cheese
  • Vegan Cheese Sauce
  • Vegan Parmesan Cheese
  • Vegan Blue Cheese Dressing
  • Nacho Cheese Doritos

How Long Does Homemade Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Vegan Cheddar Cheese Made Of?

Various nuts, most frequently cashews, almonds, and macadamias can be used to make vegan cheeses. However, unlike cheese manufactured from cow’s milk, which contains rennet, cholesterol, and other undesirable elements, these plant-based alternatives only have healthful fats.

Are Cashews Healthy?

Yes! Cashews are a good source of plant protein and fiber, they’re low in sugar and rich in heart-healthy fats.  Additionally, they are high in copper, magnesium, and manganese, all of which are necessary for brain health, immunity, bone health, and energy production.

Because of their high levels of carotenoids and polyphenolic antioxidants, cashews may help to reduce inflammation while also protecting against disease.

Can I Use Arrowroot Or Any Other Type Of Starch?

Unfortunately, only tapioca starch will cause your cheese to melt and stretch; if you substitute anything else, the result won’t be as good.

Can I Use Agar Agar Flakes Instead Of Powder? 

Yes, you can, but more of it will be required because it doesn’t melt as rapidly. Rather than using 2 tablespoons of powder, this cheese calls for 6 tablespoons of the powder Agar-Agar flakes instead. You will need three times as many flakes as powder.

Can I Add Spices? 

Yes, you are free to use any herbs and spices you wish. You can add herbs, like paprika, pepper, turmeric, and mustard powder.

What Does Vegan Cheddar Cheese Taste Like?

This recipe for vegan cheddar cheese is mild, yet flavorful. It has a great, somewhat chewy texture and a mildly tangy kick.

Can You Freeze Vegan Cheese?

Sure! Although the texture may soften slightly after thawing, you should still feel free to store any leftovers.

Can You Grate It?

Yes, you can. It is solid enough to grate. If it’s not perfect for grating when it’s just set, it’ll be the following day because it tends to become firmer the longer it’s in the fridge.

Does It Melt?

It does, indeed. Even though this cheese isn’t going to melt and spread over a pizza like other cheddar cheese, it does soften when heated. So you can definitely grate some and put it on a pizza. Even while it won’t spread, it will still taste good.

Can I Mash It?

Yes, if you want it mashed up over a cracker, it’s soft enough to do that. It is both tough enough to grate and soft enough to mash. It’s excellent stuff.

Are Nutritional Yeast Flakes Good For You?

Yes! Nutritional Yeast Flakes are a staple in many kitchens. It has a cheesy, nutty, or savory flavor. It is a vegan source of protein, B vitamins, and trace minerals that are necessary for optimal health.

It contains a high amount of vitamin B12 which helps prevent vitamin B12 deficiency in vegans. Glutathione and selenomethionine, two antioxidants found in nutritional yeast, may help protect your body from oxidative stress-induced chronic diseases.

Do I Have To Use A Blender?

While I believe that making this vegan cheddar cheese recipe in a blender is the quickest and easiest method, it is not the only option.

You could also add all of the ingredients in a food processor and blend them until the mixture is smooth and thick.

Is Vegan Cheddar Cheese Healthy?

Vegan cheddar cheese is still healthy than regular cheese that is certain. Vegan cheddar cheese is healthier than dairy cheese since it doesn’t include growth hormones, animal proteins that cause cancer, or saturated animal fat that raises cholesterol.

Give this Vegan Cheddar Cheese a try. It’s incredibly delicious and super easy. I hope you like it. As always, I would love to hear from you. So if you tried this recipe or any other from my website, please let me know how it turned out in the comments below!

If you like and enjoy this recipe, please leave a comment to let me know your feedback.

Get discounted copies of my cookbook here.

Fortunately, because of the Ads on our website, readers and subscribers of Healthier Steps are sponsoring many underprivileged families.